As we all know, the boundaries between PR and other marketing communications disciplines are coming down. I'm very much of the view that the market is coming the way of public relations, time will tell whether this is an opportunity or a threat for most PR agencies.
Within this context, the winners (and losers) of the annual PR Lions makes interesting reading. To their credit, the jury managed to resist the temptation to bang PR agencies over the head about the the quality of their work this year.
The jury seemed to agree that there was a trend of good evaluation practice within the PR agency entries, but that often the creativity of the ad agencies was more advanced than their PR agency equivilents.
The judges reckoned that the winning campaigns showed an excellent strategic approach and that a major difference between the winning entries and everyone else was the importance of long term business objectives, as opposed to a "flash in the pan" approach. The jury commended the winners on their craftmenship of amplification, without relying on paid media. They also suggested that the best campigns incorprorated real human insight and that the best and most sharable content tended to be the most fun.
That said, perhaps the biggest issue here is that most of the PR entries incorporated consumer work, there's very little volume of corporate and internal communications work entered. What constitues a pure PR agency is becoming less distinct, but, by my reckoning, about 17 out of the 90-odd Gold, Silver and Bronze PR Lions came from recognisable PR agencies. So clearly PR agencies are still not entering Cannes in large volumes, relative to the ad agencies.
I caught up with the PR Lions jury president, Ketchum's David Gallagher and he gave me his thoughts on this year's entries:
http://youtu.be/Yx1RmhFIDGk
Congratulations should go to those agencies in the UK who won. Namely: Clarion, Brooklyn Brothers, Weber Shadwick, Once Voice, Golden Goose PR and Edelman
And here are the winners of the Cannes PR Lions 2013:
Title | Client | Entrant / Agency | Country | Prize | |
DUMB WAYS TO DIE | METRO TRAINS | McCANN MELBOURNE | AUSTRALIA | Grand Prix | |
MY MATTRESS SAVINGS BANK | DES´S | VCCP Madrid / EUROPAPRESS Madrid | SPAIN | Gold Lion | |
OREO DAILY TWIST | MONDELEZ INTERNATIONAL | DRAFTFCB New York | USA | Gold Lion | |
TUNDRA SPACE SHUTTLE ENDEAVOUR CAMPAIGN | TOYOTA | SAATCHI & SAATCHI LA | USA | Gold Lion | |
METROPOLE TWEETPHONY | METROPOLE ORKEST | HAVAS WORLDWIDE AMSTERDAM | THE NETHERLANDS | Gold Lion | |
SAME SEX MARRIAGE | GOOGLE/TOUS UNIS POUR L'EGALITE | OGILVY FRANCE Paris | FRANCE | Gold Lion | |
TREE CONCERT | FRIENDS OF THE EARTH | KETCHUM PLEON Berlin / BBDO GERMANY Düsseldorf | GERMANY | Gold Lion | |
IMMORTAL FANS | SPORT CLUB RECIFE | OGILVY BRASIL São Paulo | BRAZIL | Gold Lion | |
NO MEANS NO | AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL NORWAY | TRY/APT ADVERTISING AGENCY Oslo | NORWAY | Gold Lion | |
THE CANDIDATE | HEINEKEN INTERNATIONAL | PUBLICIS ITALY Milan | ITALY | Gold Lion | |
MAKE THE POLITICIANS WORK | URA.RU CITY WEBSITE | VOSKHOD Yekaterinburg | RUSSIA | Gold Lion | |
TOXIC TOURS | GREENPEACE MEXICO | CIRCUS DF Mexico City | MEXICO | Gold Lion | |
WE BELIEVE IN D&T - AVERTING A CRISIS | THE DESIGN AND TECHNOLOGY ASSOCIATION | WEBER SHANDWICK London | UNITED KINGDOM | Gold Lion | |
DUMB WAYS TO DIE | METRO TRAINS | McCANN MELBOURNE | AUSTRALIA | Gold Lion | |
REAL BEAUTY SKETCHES | UNILEVER | OGILVY BRASIL São Paulo | BRAZIL | Gold Lion | |
MAKE THE POLITICIANS WORK | URA.RU CITY WEBSITE | VOSKHOD Yekaterinburg | RUSSIA | Gold Lion | |
AMAZING MINDREADER | FEBELFIN | DUVAL GUILLAUME MODEM Antwerp | BELGIUM | Gold Lion | |
WE ARE DAVID BAILEY | SAMSUNG | CHEIL UK | UNITED KINGDOM | Gold Lion | |
PUTTING SEA CONTAINERS ON THE MAP | THE DEERBROOK GROUP | GOLDEN GOOSE PR Surrey | UNITED KINGDOM | Gold Lion | |
TUNDRA SPACE SHUTTLE ENDEAVOUR CAMPAIGN | TOYOTA | SAATCHI & SAATCHI LA | USA | Gold Lion | |
REAL BEAUTY SKETCHES | UNILEVER | OGILVY BRASIL São Paulo | BRAZIL | Gold Lion | |
AXE MORNING AFTER PILLOW | UNILEVER | DDB LATINA PUERTO RICO San Juan | PUERTO RICO | Silver Lion | |
DUREXPERIMENT FUNDAWEAR | RECKITT BENCKISER | HAVAS WORLDWIDE AUSTRALIA North Sydney / FRANK PR SYDNEY | AUSTRALIA | Silver Lion | |
ADOPT A POTHOLE PROJECT | APOLLO TYRES | PUBLICIS COMMUNICATIONS Gurgaon | INDIA | Silver Lion | |
SOLAR CHARGING DUMMIES | SPIES TRAVELS | ROBERT/BOISEN & LIKE-MINDED Copenhagen | DENMARK | Silver Lion | |
BRIDGE OF LIFE | SAMSUNG LIFE INSURANCE | CHEIL WORLDWIDE Seoul | SOUTH KOREA | Silver Lion | |
EXPERIENCE: HALO FOR HALO 4 | MICROSOFT | EDELMAN London | UNITED KINGDOM | Silver Lion | |
WAITING. FOR SEVEN YEARS. | FOUNDATION “FOR LIFE – FOR ORGAN DONATION” | OGILVY GERMANY Frankfurt | GERMANY | Silver Lion | |
DRIVING DOGS | SPCA NEW ZEALAND | DRAFTFCB NEW ZEALAND Auckland | NEW ZEALAND | Silver Lion | |
THE MOST POWERFUL ARM EVER INVENTED | SAVE OUR SONS & DUCHENNE FOUNDATION | RED AGENCY Sydney | AUSTRALIA | Silver Lion | |
DAYS OF HOPE | DIAKONIE FRANKFURT & PARTNERS, SAMUSOCIAL, SPRAVEDLIVAYA POMOSCH, SHELTER, SOZIALWERKE PFARRER SIEBER, POLSKI CZERWONY KRZYZ | SAATCHI & SAATCHI Berlin | GERMANY | Silver Lion | |
A BOY AND HIS ATOM: THE WORLD’S SMALLEST MOVIE | IBM | OGILVY NEW YORK | USA | Silver Lion | |
NO NAME MATCH | UNICEF | ONIRIA/TBWA Asuncion | PARAGUAY | Silver Lion | |
FOLLOW2UNFOLLOW | PUERTO RICO GOVERNMENT | STARCOM MEDIAVEST GROUP San Juan | PUERTO RICO | Silver Lion | |
SMOKING KID | THAI HEALTH PROMOTION FOUNDATION | OGILVY & MATHER Bangkok | THAILAND | Silver Lion | |
MY BLOOD IS RED AND BLACK | HEMOBA / ESPORTE CLUBE VITÓRIA | LEO BURNETT TAILOR MADE São Paulo | BRAZIL | Silver Lion | |
DONATE YOUR FACEBOOK TIMELINE | ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE INTERNATIONAL | OGILVY GROUP Brussels | BELGIUM | Silver Lion | |
CIVIL RIGHTS | CIVIL RIGHTS DEFENDERS | PRIME Stockholm | SWEDEN | Silver Lion | |
CENSORED TWEET | AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL | DDB BRASIL São Paulo | BRAZIL | Silver Lion | |
WAITING. FOR SEVEN YEARS. | FOUNDATION “FOR LIFE – FOR ORGAN DONATION” | OGILVY GERMANY Frankfurt | GERMANY | Silver Lion | |
UPPER CLASS PARK BENCH | VIRGIN ATLANTIC AIRWAYS | Y&R New York | USA | Silver Lion | |
FAIR GO BRO | VIRGIN MOBILE AUSTRALIA | ONE GREEN BEAN Sydney / HAVAS WORLDWIDE AUSTRALIA North Sydney | AUSTRALIA | Silver Lion | |
DEFORESTED FIELD | WWF | GREY 141 GROUP São Paulo | BRAZIL | Silver Lion | |
DAYS OF HOPE | DIAKONIE FRANKFURT & PARTNERS, SAMUSOCIAL, SPRAVEDLIVAYA POMOSCH, SHELTER, SOZIALWERKE PFARRER SIEBER, POLSKI CZERWONY KRZYZ | SAATCHI & SAATCHI Berlin | GERMANY | Silver Lion | |
INMESSIONANTE | PEPSICO ARGENTINA | ADVERPR Buenos Aires / BBDO ARGENTINA Buenos Aires | ARGENTINA | Silver Lion | |
MY MATTRESS SAVINGS BANK | DES´S | VCCP Madrid / EUROPAPRESS Madrid | SPAIN | Silver Lion | |
EXPERIENCE: HALO FOR HALO 4 | MICROSOFT | EDELMAN London | UNITED KINGDOM | Silver Lion | |
THE BREAD OF MEMORY | AMIA | OGILVY & MATHER ARGENTINA Buenos Aires | ARGENTINA | Silver Lion | |
MAKE IT TO MUSE | STUDIO BRUSSELS | MORTIERBRIGADE Brussels / VRT Brussels | BELGIUM | Silver Lion | |
DAYS OF HOPE | DIAKONIE FRANKFURT & PARTNERS, SAMUSOCIAL, SPRAVEDLIVAYA POMOSCH, SHELTER, SOZIALWERKE PFARRER SIEBER, POLSKI CZERWONY KRZYZ | SAATCHI & SAATCHI Berlin | GERMANY | Silver Lion | |
NATIONAL NIGHT | PERFETTI VAN MELLE | BBH ASIA PACIFIC Singapore | SINGAPORE | Bronze Lion | |
TOASTIE KNIFE | WARBURTONS | CLARION COMMUNICATIONS London | UNITED KINGDOM | Bronze Lion | |
VOICE DRIVER | NISSAN | TBWAHAKUHODO Tokyo | JAPAN | Bronze Lion | |
THE AUDIOGUIDE PROJECT | TOCHKA G | Y&R RUSSIA Moscow | RUSSIA | Bronze Lion | |
ICELAND BY ANOTHER NAME | PROMOTE ICELAND | THE BROOKLYN BROTHERS London | UNITED KINGDOM | Bronze Lion | |
PRmoment Leaders
PRmoment Leaders is our new subscription-based learning programme and community, built by PRmoment specifically for the next generation of PR and communications leaders to learn, network, and lead.
PRmoment LeadersIf you enjoyed this article, sign up for free to our twice weekly editorial alert.
We have six email alerts in total - covering ESG, internal comms, PR jobs and events. Enter your email address below to find out more: